One evening in September, Elisabeth Williams was on the patio of her apartment on Manhattan’s Upper West Side when she heard a strange, high-pitched shriek. She often watched pigeons, blue jays, and swallows from that patio, but she had never heard anything like this. The sound, it turned out, came from a family of barn owls, a kind of owl that is almost never seen in New York City. Experts believe they are the first barn owls known to nest in Manhattan.
For weeks, Williams and her husband, Sam, kept hearing the screech, and a bird app on her phone suggested it was a barn owl. Then, on the evening of October 3, Sam saw a dark shape fly past. Elisabeth quickly took a photo. It seemed too dark to show anything, but when she checked it, she saw a barn owl with a heart-shaped face. She named it Scotty.
Scotty was not alone. A block away, the couple spotted a whole family of barn owls on a water tower, one of the big wooden tanks that sit on top of many New York buildings. This tower stands on a building on West 75th Street, near Central Park. The couple sent their pictures to a local news site, and soon the owls were on TV and all over social media.
Now crowds of birdwatchers gather every night to see them. One of them, David Barrett, has photographed two adult owls and up to six young ones, which live in a hole in the tower. Not everyone loved the noise at first, though. A neighbour, Thomas Obersteiner, said the screeching sounded like someone “being murdered outside,” and more than once, he and his wife ran to their children’s room because they thought one of the kids was hurt.
The nest is special because New York is at the northern edge of the area where barn owls live, and their numbers in the state have dropped sharply. “The presence of a nest right in the middle of the country’s biggest city is really exciting,” said Jessica Wilson of the NYC Bird Alliance, a local bird group.
Wilson also has a worry. Barn owls eat mice and rats, and many rats in the city are killed with poison. When an owl eats a poisoned rat, the poison can kill the owl too, and a barn owl may eat several rats a day.
In October, the young owls were taking their first test flights around the water tower at night while their parents hunted. “They fly really close, almost like they’re divebombing us,” Sam said.
Sources: The New York Times, CBS News New York, AP
Elisabeth Williams likes to watch the birds from the patio of her apartment on Manhattan’s Upper West Side: swallows, blue jays, and pigeons sailing by. So when a breathy, high-pitched shriek rang out one evening in September, she knew it was no ordinary city bird. The source turned out to be a family of barn owls, which experts believe are the first barn owls known to have nested in Manhattan.
Williams and her husband, Sam, kept hearing the screech night after night, and a bird app on her phone pointed to a barn owl. On the evening of October 3, Sam was on the patio when a dark blur flew past. Elisabeth snapped a picture that looked far too dark to be useful, but when she checked it, there it was: a barn owl, with the pale, heart-shaped face the species is known for. She named it Scotty.
Scotty, it turned out, had company. A block away, the couple could just make out an entire owl family perched on a water tower, one of the large wooden tanks that sit on many New York rooftops. This one is on a building on West 75th Street, near Central Park. The Williamses sent their photos to a local news site, and from there the story spread to local TV and social media.
Since then, crowds of birdwatchers have been arriving after dark to catch a glimpse. Not every neighbour was charmed at first. Thomas Obersteiner said the screeching sounded like someone “being murdered outside,” and he and his wife ran to their children’s room more than once, convinced one of them was hurt. Now he lets photographers use his roof deck almost every night, calling it “probably the best location in town right now.” One night, 20 people showed up.
Among the regulars is David Barrett, a local birdwatcher, who has photographed two adults and up to six young owls living in a hole in the tower. “It’s a truly special experience,” he said.
The excitement is about more than a cute photo. New York sits at the northern limit of the barn owl’s range, and the species has declined sharply in the state as land development has eaten into its habitat. “The presence of a nest right in the middle of the country’s biggest city is really exciting,” said Jessica Wilson, executive director of the NYC Bird Alliance.
Wilson also raised a concern. Many of the city’s rats are killed with rodenticide, a type of poison, and owls that eat them can be poisoned in turn. “If barn owls are eating several rats a day, they are likely to fall prey to this horrible death,” she said. New Yorkers know that risk well: in 2024, Flaco, a much-loved owl that had escaped from the Central Park Zoo, died after hitting a building, and tests found rat poison in his body.
In October, the young owls were making their first test flights around the tower while their parents hunted. The Williamses are happy to give them room. “They fly really close, almost like they’re divebombing us,” Sam said.
Sources: The New York Times, CBS News New York, AP, Smithsonian









